November 20, 2026 at 5:30 a.m.

Cathy May (Foley) Simmons



Cathy May (Foley) Simmons passed away peacefully from Alzheimer’s in the early morning of November 13 after spending a quiet, calm evening with the love of her life and husband of 52 years, Gary Bethel Simmons. Born on March 27, 1949 to Rose May and Wallace “Wally” Foley, Cathy grew up in the same Montello farmhouse her father was born in. She went to a small one-room schoolhouse until grade six before moving into town where she and her three sisters (Colleen, Claudette and Corrine) played and spent time with family. Cathy was social from the beginning, focusing on her relationships and friends from several schools and leaning fully into her “Chatty Cathy” persona, in the most enduring of ways. In high school, she was a cheerleader and Homecoming Queen as a sophomore. 

Cathy pursued a career in nursing, attending one of the first nurse practitioner programs in the state focused on women’s health and pregnancy through UW-Madison. She brought her caring, supportive and exuberant personality into the field of nursing where she touched the lives of women and families at the Nekoosa Clinic, Marshfield Clinic and Planned Parenthood.

The love affair with Gary of over 50 years began with a chance encounter in the heart of San Francisco. This would later be known as The San Francisco Connection.

Gary’s parents, Bethel and Eleanor Simmons, first met in San Francisco, and years later their daughter Barbara would live in the City by the Bay. Gary flew out over the holidays to visit his sister, while Cathy went to visit her former college roommate, Barbara. Cathy and Gary met for the first time that same holiday weekend, sparks flew, and Cupid’s bow hit the mark. A whirlwind romance ensued months later back in Wisconsin, and the two exchanged wedding vows in Madison on June 15, 1974.

For the next 33 years, Wisconsin Rapids would be home, where they worked diligently and passionately at their lifelong careers. Cathy as a nurse practitioner and Gary as a teacher. In 1978, Chad Bethel Simmons entered the world, and three years later son Ryan James Simmons completed their family. Cathy and Gary often referred to their two boys as their greatest assets in their years together.

Their home in Rapids was always Cathy’s happy place, together with Gary always planning out the next family vacation or celebration of birthdays, anniversaries, holiday gatherings, or adjusting to the boys’ activities schedules. And there would be endless dialogue about retirement life, with always one eye solidly on the cabin Up North. So many of these conversations took place on Friday and Saturday nights either out on the backyard deck or the downstairs bar room. Dreams were shared, plans were temporarily put in place, and a review of the week’s events were all addressed over a brandy old fashioned with music from their wonder years playing nonstop in the background. Their dog Frisco usually accompanied them, eagerly searching for pretzel morsels conveniently scattered on the backyard deck or barroom floor. Saturday nights became known as Steak Night at the Grill, a weekend tradition the two carried on into their retirement home in the Northwoods.

Their years in Rapids were filled with wonderful memories of solid friendships established and annual traditions followed. The yearly Mistletoe Ball was a dress-to-the-nines affair, with a cocktail party at the house followed by appetizers, chocolates, and dancing to live bands at the Mead Inn. The end-of-the-school-year get-together was the official ringing in of the summer season. Summers during those years, aside from the boys’ baseball tournaments, brought two givens: family vacations and trips Up North to the Johnson Lake cabin.

The Virgin Pines Resort, established in 1940 and owned and operated by Petronella and Alphonse Yuodsnukis, Gary’s grandparents and later by Bethel and Eleanor Simmons, was Cathy and Gary’s summer retreat for their family, with Cabin #6 becoming their second home, with the boys on or near the water nonstop. 

In addition to family cookouts and firepit gatherings, there were numerous outings to iconic supper clubs of the Northwoods, including the traditional Wisconsin Friday Night fish fry and time spent at the piano bars. Cathy loved to sing, and she could often be heard crooning her favorite tunes: “Scotch and Soda” and “Blue Moon.” The Northwestern Hotel and Bar, later reincarnated as Bethel’s Bar in downtown Woodruff, would often be the last stop after the annual Family Night, a summertime tradition for the family.

Summertime trips with the boys were literally all over the U.S. map: from Cooperstown, N.Y. (Baseball Hall of Fame), Disneyworld, Grand Canyon, New York City, Niagara Falls, to Baltimore, New Orleans, Cape Cod, and of course, San Francisco. Cathy often said that traveling by car and train during those years gave the boys an opportunity to see what this place called America was all about. 

There were also opportunities for Cathy to connect on a regular basis with her siblings and Montello friends. Their trips to Montello also allowed the boys to spend time with Grandma Rose May Foley. Whenever the Foleys got together, the proverbial Sisters Photo Shoot was etched in stone. The four sisters — Colleen, Cathy, Claudette, Corrine — have been the legend of family photo album folklore.

In 1984, Cathy and Gary spearheaded a drive to attend one Badger football game a year with friends and family from Rapids, Montello, and the Madison area. This Game Day experience continued for 40 years, a testimony to the value of friendship and tradition. Cathy and Gary also carried their interest in Badger football by securing season tickets for both, another activity in which they could spend time together in a city they came to love.

Retirement came in the spring of 2007, and with it came a new, brief chapter with a move to downtown Madison. The experience of downtown living brought new cultural and social opportunities, and Cathy and Gary embraced them all. In 2009, Cathy decided she wanted to participate in the Crazylegs Classic with Gary, a 5-mile run held every year beginning at the Capitol and ending in Camp Randall Stadium. Cathy, an avid walker, had never run a distance race. But in true Cathy fashion, with grit and determination, she completed her first run nonstop, crossing the finish line with Gary in Camp Randall Stadium. Chalk one up for the Irish girl from Montello.

In 2010, Cathy and Gary moved to their new retirement home on Johnson Lake in the exact location where Cabin #6 occupied the property since 1940. For the next 16 years the two would enjoy their new digs spending time with friends and family, spending hours on the deck conversing and taking in the tranquility of their new homestead. In those years for Cathy, it was in the mundane things that brought her happiness and contentment: coffee time, music time, deck time, fire pit conversations, wrapping herself in comfy quilts next to the warmth from the nearby fireplace, watching PBS mysteries with a big bowl of ice cream — Cathy loved her ice cream. Catching a few innings of the Brewers — and her favorite player, Brice Turang (“turang, turang, turang”) on the Tube. FaceTiming the boys, daughter-in-law Carrie, and granddaughter Ember rounded out a perfect week. Retirement also brought volunteering opportunities for Cathy. She and Gary joined the Lakeland Badger Chapter of the UW Alumni Association. As lifelong Badger fans (they attended the 2011 Rose Bowl), this was an excellent opportunity to meet people with a common interest. Cathy and Gary also became docents at the Dr. Kate Museum in Woodruff. This was the perfect fit, as Cathy was a nurse practitioner in reproductive health and Gary was a Dr. Kate baby. For 10 years this was the most rewarding experience of their retirement years. For Cathy, jigsaw puzzles also occupied much of her retirement time, with the walls of her home covered with her framed puzzles.  

Cathy’s biggest puzzle-like challenge came in early 2013 with a diagnosis of mild cognitive impairment, turning to Alzheimer’s Disease a few years later. For over 12 years, Cathy handled The Long Goodbye with aplomb and tenacity. In the interim, she and Gary made the ultimate trip to Ireland and England. As a Foley, she hoisted a pint of Guinness in Dublin. As a Beatles fan, she quaffed a few brews in Liverpool at the Cavern Club as she joined the raucous crowd singing Beatles songs. She sipped champagne in the garden of Shakespeare’s home in Stratford-on-Avon. While visiting son Ryan in Kauai, she strolled the sands of Poipu Beach and enjoyed a sunset cruise along the Nepali Coast. Cathy and Gary continued their extended spring break treks to Fort Myers Beach, getting together with the boys and family, taking in the sand, surf, and tiki bar vibe.

As always, her Northwoods home was her comfort zone, basking in the warmth of family and friends, watching the loons do their water ballet, while the eagles soared above, keeping watch over Cathy and Gary. Even under the advancing ravages of her devastating disease, Cathy managed her remaining time with an Irish temperament and sense of humor. The Montello girl — who married the Woodruff boy, brought forever together by the San Francisco Connection — had completed the Circle of Life. The Fab Four got it right: All you need is love. Love is all you need. Cathy was carried swiftly and gently to the front steps of love and peace on eagle’s wings. Cathy will continue to caress the heart and soul of all those she touched in this life.

Cathy was a true connector. No matter the situation or location, she found a way to strike up a conversation, crack a joke, give a hug or in more than one instance, hold a baby.  

Cathy is predeceased by her mother Rose May (Burlingame) Foley, father Wallace “Wally” John Foley and many loving and influential aunts and uncles from both the Burlingame and Foley families. Cathy is survived by her sisters Colleen (Foley) Schultz, Claudette (Foley) Higgins, Corrine (Foley) Kanke, sons Ryan and Chad Simmons, her daughter-in-law Carrie Simmons, her granddaughter Ember Simmons, her loving husband Gary Bethel Simmons and so many nieces and nephews from both Foley and Simmons families. 

The family encourages everyone reading this to approach life like Cathy would, open mind, open heart, and yes, a willingness to gab and connect with others. In lieu of flowers or cards, the family encourages people to make a contribution, if you are able, to the Wisconsin Alzheimer’s Association:  https://www.alz.org/wi.

Online condolences may be shared at www.nimsgernfuneral.com. Nimsgern Funeral & Cremation Services is serving the family.


Comments:

You must login to comment.

MINOCQUA WEATHER

WEATHER SPONSORED BY

250 X 250 AD
250 X 250 AD
250 X 250 AD

Events

November

SU
MO
TU
WE
TH
FR
SA
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
29
30
1
2
3
4
5
SUN
MON
TUE
WED
THU
FRI
SAT
SUN MON TUE WED THU FRI SAT
25 26 27 28 29 30 31
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30 1 2 3 4 5

To Submit an Event Sign in first

Today's Events

No calendar events have been scheduled for today.

250 X 250 AD